One of the things I miss dearly about the G.O.D. University is their program of international film. I was fortunate to have discovered this treasure as a freshman with an interest in German things so I went to see the German films. And I had my mind blown by New German Cinema. One of the great things about the international film at my alma mater was that they have multiple showing of each of the typically three films they show in a week. So I could have my mind blown twice a week by the same Werner Herzog film. (And somehow I found the time to accommodate this mind blowing.)
As such I spent a fair amount of time hanging around in the lobby waiting for the previous film to end. The auditorium was in a building that also housed departments in the social sciences and so there was various advertising for the corresponding majors. It was from hanging around here that I discovered a large display for the women's studies minor. Women's studies at the G.O.D. U.? In the word's of young Wiggum, that's unpossible. Intrigued, I studied this display. There were images of women in Africa. Women in Asia. Women in South America. Interspersed among the luckier natives might be a young beaming blond girl presumably a student of this women's studies program who was simultaneously studying "women" and bringing them into the modern age.
Even ten years ago (ten years ago! I'm so old), I considered myself a feminist but something about this advertisement struck me wrong. The women being studied were "some other women" not our own women. And although at that time I was more involved in activism, it seemed to me like you might as well join the Peace Corps as minor in women's studies.
Fast forward a few years, and now I was a grad student at the G.O.D.U. where I was doing a thesis on abortion in German film. I applied for a small grant from the institute for women's research that housed this women's studies minor. I did not get any money. Neither did any of my fellow students who applied on other German women's topics. This just reaffirmed in my mind that this institute was not interested in women historically or European women.
Fast forward even more years, I'm now a PhD student at a large public Midwestern university pursuing an external minor in women's studies. In my graduate level women's studies class this semester, we each introduced ourselves and our research interests in women's studies. I mentioned that I had done a thesis on abortion in German silent film at the G.O.D.U. At the end of class my professor asked me if it was difficult to do that kind of thesis at the G.O.D.U. I answered honestly that it wasn't hard in my department but it might have been in another department.
Three weeks ago the G.O.D.U. announces that is "streamlining" this women's institute by closing it and that the women's studies minor will now be housed in sociology.
When I heard this I was saddened, but I was neither surprised nor angered. I looked at their website and discovered that they were more friendly to the humanities than I had thought and even helped with the German women writer's project. But even for being "interdisciplinary" they still had a strong bias for the social sciences. Missing was any account of gender or sexuality. There was also a sense that some woman "here" need to "help a sister out" over "there." In terms of a history of academic feminism, they were stuck in the late seventies.
Which is a real problem for the G.O.D.U. What do you do when the rest of women's studies has moved away from essentialism? What do you do with theories of gender? What about sexuality? To be complete, these kinds of hand-wringing questions are being asked at women's studies programs all over the country. But sticking your head in the sand (at least in the way it is advertised - I have never taken a women's studies course at the G.O.D.U.) in pretending that these issues don't exist or that Judith Butler and bell hooks were never born seems not much better than shutting down completely.
I should be angry that even this last symbol of the dialogue of the G.O.D.U. and women's studies is gone. I should be angry that this justifies even more my professor's comment to me just in August. I should have participated in the online discussions. I should have written letters to various administrative men. But I'm a bad feminist in that I've become too cynical to think that activism means something, especially to a patriarchy.
So instead I let it fester for a couple of weeks, because there is still that part of me that believes in agency and activism. It's hard spot to negotiate. But that's part of what a university should be about - sitting in those hard spots, negotiating, not streamlining or ignoring those moments of tension. And I wish my alma mater had more courage to go there because in the end they haven't silenced women of my religion, but rather silenced religion in women's studies.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


3 comments:
Why am I not surprised?
I'm not surprised either and I'm pretty cynical that any kind of protest is going to change the current situation.
The question of women's studies within a patriarchal culture reminds me of a quote I read from a Muslim woman who said that "If those who condemn me are also those who will judge me, I have no chance." I understood the desperation she expressed having sadly felt it so many times. I long to be there when someday Eve explains how things how things really are.
BTW did you know they now make a Burka Barbie? Mutti
Post a Comment