Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Holy Envy

I've been wishing I was Catholic lately. My sister Carrie Nation is partly to blame for this. She came and visited me in Madtown in July and brought the delightful TV series “Ballyk” with her. This drama/comedy/soap-opera tells the story of an English Catholic priest whose first parish is in the small Irish village “Ballyk.” Although the series is similar to other Britcoms which follow the misadventures of an outsider in a rural setting, I fell in love with it. I have a soft spot for depictions of people trying to live their religion. The English priest quickly becomes an important member of their community, for both believers and non-believers. He lives among them, drinks with them, and listens to them. The villagers grow to trust him as he becomes on of them and they realize he takes their concerns seriously. He cultivates their trust and friendship without compromising his own (Catholic) beliefs (at least in the first two seasons . . .).

What would it be like to have a professional clergy? Someone who was looking out for the welfare of his congregation 24/7? Someone who had the time and training to build and maintain a community? As much as I love the concept of a lay clergy, I am sometimes jealous of a professional clergy with their entire time devoted to their congregation. Pastoral care is difficult enough without adding the distractions of a career and family.

The week Car came to visit, the speakers in church were talking about “the sacred and the gospel.” This was a difficult topic, because the sacred really doesn't exist in Mormonism and we don't really realize it. When Moroni appeared to Joseph and made him dig up the gold plates out of the ground, any sacred distance (and sacred time) was collapsed. Joseph's theology led to a sacralization of everything into his radical version of monism. This leads to some apparent paradoxes, which even came up in the talks. The woman speaking mentioned wishing that she had studied more spiritual things, yet realized that her secular knowledge was fulfilling prophetic counsel. Of course Mormon scripture doesn't really make this distinction. She also spoke about God answering her prayers to find a lost Frisbee and also to send her comfort after her miscarriage. One of those is completely mundane, yet the Mormon God cares about both.

One of the byproducts of the collapse of sacred distance is that we don't re/create the sacred in our practices. How else could we in good conscience worship regularly in basketball courts? Our church buildings are ultra-utilitarian, not (just) because of an inherited protestantism, but because if everything is sacred we don't need (or can't) create the sacred with architecture. (Obviously, this is one of the many paradoxes of Mormonism, both heuristically and in our own practice (for example, where does the temple fit?).) Although I appreciate this aspect of Mormonism, I nevertheless long for a sense of the sacred in my spiritual life. I love the sacred space that other churches (especially Catholics) create and share with everyone. Some of my favorite holy places are the Spanish catholic missions in the southwest. It doesn't get any better than this.

A corollary to this is music. Last week I heard the girls choir from Madtown's German sister city's Catholic cathdral. They sang sacred music from a variety of Christian traditions, including medieval Catholicism and some gorgeous Ave Marias. In addition to the fact that I'm an early music junkie, I was really moved by the veneration of Mary in these pieces. I wish we could do a little of that in Mormonism. Surely if we can sing “Praise to Man,” we could stand the occasional “Ave Maria”?

And while I of course am more jealous of the music tradition in the Lutheran and Anglican churches, I still am envious of the seriousness taken with the music in Catholicism. The choir was well trained and the organist and conductor professional. Yes, we've got the MoTab and organists, but could imagine something like that at the ward level? I freely admit that I'm pagan enough to feel the spirit in aesthetic experiences.

The concert was crawling with Catholics. It was sponsored by the diocese and there were plenty of people wearing their religion on their sleeve—from dogcollar to Catholic t-shirts. As I was leaving the parking garage, I was behind a car advertising a Catholic radio station. I've been listening to it the last week while driving around. Admittedly it's not been that much, but I'm still impressed by both what Mormons have in common with Catholics and what we could learn from them. I've heard programs on the healthcare/birth-control controversy, the censuring of the American nuns (in support of the nuns), dealing with anti-Catholic sentiment, working for peace, and fostering ecumenical dialogue. I like that there seems to be a distinct variety of opinions expressed (granted this could be from by own superficial understanding (which of course, is the basis of this entire post)). There seems to be more possibility for diversity.

Of course, like for Mormons, this depends in large part on those in charge. There was a new bishop put in here in Madtown last year who is quite conservative and has caused a minor exodus in the area. In fact one of the local Catholic elementary schools had to close because enough parents are so against the changes this bishop has made in the diocese they withdrew their children and made the school unsustainable. It's sad to me to read letters to the editor in the secular press from progressive Catholics trying to find their place under the new regime.

After four years of living in Madtown, my ward has had a fair amount of turnover. Some of the people who made it clear to my husband and me when we moved in that they did not approve of our choices, have moved out this summer. I've had to think a lot about trying to forgive. I'm really good at holding grudges. Especially when people in positions of power use that opportunity to marginalize you and then act as if it's your fault that you have no desire to interact with them. Being here, I've had to go on autopilot in order to continue to worship with a community I didn't seem to belong to. I seriously considered stopping attending at all, but received a sure confirmation that I needed to continue to attend and serve in my callings, as difficult as it might be. I've only become aware in the last few months how many other people on my ward also feel left out. Especially this summer as so many at the center of the ward activity have moved out, I've discovered how many members also feel peripheral, for geographic, linguistic, age, or lifestyle reasons.

I've also come to understand why a vocal block of the ward has done this. Most of them are the male grad students and their wives, so they are young and often newly married with a child or two or more on the way. This is a highly stressful time of life and encompasses a number of major identity shifts as they enter into the roles of husband and wife, father and mother, provider and nurturer, and usually are living away from home for the first time (with the exception of the mission). They are trying to figure out where they fit in and tend to define themselves and others against a particular version of Mormonism that privileges “traditional” families, where the woman stays home with children and the husband works outside the home. These are quick boundary markers that can be applied at a glance, separating the wheat from the tares without having to do the work of nuance. And since these are the people in auxiliary and priesthood presidencies and the bishopric, it has had a major impact on how the ward functions.

As I've prayed to be able to enjoy church and forgive those who've made my church experience in Madison miserable, I've been granted some mercies. One of those is a great set of non-traditional visiting teachers. Another is to strengthen friendships with some of those also on the margins. I've enjoyed some atoning healing and learned how much I must rely on Jesus to make up for my weakness. Although I've tried to do my best, the last few years have been difficult. I've underperformed in so many aspects of my life, including my own pastoral responsibilities. I've learned that I must repent of my withdrawal from my fellow saints and other friends. I'm embarrassed by how many emails and phone calls I've left unanswered from so many friends, because of stress, guilt, and paralyzing fear that I didn't deserve anyone's concern. I'm slowly getting to a point that I feel I can reach out more and even feel compelled and excited to.

I wish I could go to confession and get a plan on how to repent. Instead I will just have to ask my friends' forgiveness and strive to maintain and building new relationships. Community is important, immediately around you and in your greater circle. Even the Catholics know this.

7 comments:

Schmath said...

I wish we could hear Ave Maria in our church too! I kinda want to try to talk my bishopric into it, but It seems like that song is mentioned specifically in the handbook.

I think the people who offend us at church are just people, and that not everything they say or think or do in an effort to fulfill their callings is inspired. Plus, they probably had weird childhoods. Just blame it on their parents.

The Old Cowboy said...

I have a great deal of respect and admiration for my friends who are believing, practicing Catholics. This was not always the case. As a young dog I had little respect for the Catholic church because of historic repression, etc. but as I have gained a measure of maturity that has changed. I think many of the Romanesque, Gothic and even Byzantine churches are beautiful and awe inspiring. Napoleon Bonaparte is reputed to have said that no man could stand in the nave of Chartres Cathedral and deny the existence of God. The mission church of San Xavier del Bac in Tucson is one of the most beautiful and inspiring churches I have ever been in. With a few exceptions ours suffer from a heavy dose of Cromwellian Puritanism. At least we now have spires on them so they don't look as much like a Toyota dealership. Sometimes we try really hard to not be like the other Christian churches--so hard that we shoot ourselves in the foot. Several years ago the church building people tore down a tabernacle in Coalville, Utah. A number of the local people were upset, signed petitions, etc, along with a number of outsiders. The response was "We are in the business of saving souls, not buildings." I am firmly in the camp that believes a genuinely beautiful building can help in the saving of souls. Example: all of the gospel can be found in the stained glass of the medieval cathedrals in Europe. As for music, "Ave Maria" was sung by Kiri Te Kanawa at the Salt Lake Tabernacle and the last I heard the building was still standing. Of course, not long after that they closed it to make it earth quake proof. The worst was one of our Bishops on Easter Sunday allowed no Easter program and only one speaker managed to acknowledge Easter. As the meeting was concluding the Bishop said "It has come to my attention that today is Easter so we will sing page whatever instead of the scheduled closing song."
I have been marginalized for years. I have been divorced and I wear a beard--I must be bad! The first Bishop in Mesa that let me do something commensurate with my abilities was Bishop Rohner, followed by Bishop Shreeve.(Ward clerk and teaching Gospel Doctrine). At times during all those years it was difficult to remember that the Gospel is true despite the church culture. Anyway, I love beautiful buildings and beautiful music-too bad I have to go to non-LDS churches to find the combo.

REC said...

Bless me Sarah, for I have sinned. I have not reached out to you enough, prayed for you enough or counseled with you enough. But I am relieved that you have independently and very correctly made a very important realization - namely that many in the Congregation feel marginalized due to the ineptitude and/or insecurity of those in positions of responsibility. Your ability to reach out to these individuals not only brings joy and peace to them but to you so that this finally becomes the reason to continue to attend, i.e., sustaining one another, showing love to another, and in doing so, rising above the fray.
The Lay Leadership is quite an experiment. Sometimes it works well but more often it is an endurance contest for us on both sides. But unlike the Catholic Bishop who is there at the pleasure of the Vatican for an unknown time, we do know there is an end-point in a calling. Change will come.
I was so intrigued by the analyses you made of differences in the architecture, music, art, etc. Very interesting comparisons and very thought provoking.
I have been thinking a lot lately about life in the Village, especially the hierarchy created by the positions that people are given which result in judgements being made about your worthiness and/or value as a person or a family group, since the positions are bestowed based on "inspiration" and thus an aura of "Specialness" is also bestowed. An unseemly posturing enters into the congregation as some try to demonstrate how supremely important and in the know they are. In addition, I have been particularly concerned about how the Village treats its aging members. I suppose that our common ground is that the Village defines "In" and "Out" in a way that would make the High School bullies cry with envy.
Illegitamtum Non Carborundum continues to sustain us!

The Old Cowboy said...

Incidentally, there is no mention of "Ave Maria" in the Handbook of Instructions version 2, available online. The MoTabs sang it at the Salt Lake Cathedral in 1993.

Artax said...

Thanks for this post. There is so much that I admire in it. I, too, have felt marginalized at times, and have felt that church attendance was often just endurance. I admire your generosity in acknowledging that others are under their own stresses. I also admire your ability to realize that the marginalization is not your fault. And most of all, I admire your desire to repent and be a better neighbor yourself. As an introvert, I need to remember this more myself and reach out.

Thora said...

I kept meaning to comment on this post - it affected me a lot, but I didn't quite know what to say, and I didn't want to dash off a thoughtless comment, and then I had a baby and then I thought up more excuses, and then I realized this is probably exactly how I end up marginalizing people without meaning to, instead of reaching out.

So I finally say some things, even if they aren't the right things. When I visited the Notre Dame cathedral, it was an incredibly religious experience - I was on the verge of tears the whole time, for no specific reason, it just touched me that much (and I am not a crier at all...) I think that some religious truths are easier seen through the guise of other religious traditions (sometimes because they're better at them than we are). It's one reason I love studying religions.

I am the group that you describe - the ones in the center. And I wish I knew better how to reach out - I'm glad that you're choosing both to still go (after all, it's true that there are lots of people on the margins, and if they stop coming, then the margins will never become the center, or even close to it), and reaching out yourself. I wish we were in your ward, or vice versa. As always, your writing is so clear and well thought out. Avram and I have often remarked on what a clear thinker you are - a trait we greatly admire - you make confusing topics so clear in print and then in thought.

Carrie Nation said...

I must ask your forgiveness for not even reading this post until now. I wish I had for your sake and mine. So much of what you have been through, I have been going through the last couple years. In different ways, and I know we've talked about all of this. But I wish I had read your post sooner. I have a lot to learn from your humility and efforts to reach out. Obviously, since I haven't even checked my own sister's or father's blogs in six months or so. And, by the way, I love your point about "Praise to the Man". I don't think there's anything wrong with a little reverence for the woman who gave birth to and raised the Son of God. Linus just mentioned the other day in a similar discussion we were having, that there is too much timidity in our church. (It made me think of your brass players.) Anyway, maybe I'll go to midnight mass this year at St. Michael's. :-)