A Brief Report on the most recent church goings ons. The book club was a mild success, in that two people came this time and we got the next two months assigned. In August we are reading a book about the languages of love (there are apparently five of them) and how to improve communication with our spouses. I suppose these languages will be French, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish and, um, Romanian? We will see.
Our talks went well. I finally finished reading the last book of a multi-volume fantasy series with overtly Christian themes (no, not the one with the lion, the one that also masquerades as a Bildungsroman , or better yet, the great British boarding school multi-part novel). Since I no longer had any excuses, I wrote my talk out on overcoming selfishness on Sunday morning. I managed to refer to said fantasy book, Lacan's mirror theory and Nietzsche, so although I forgot the Goethe quote I was going to put in, I called it a success. Matt prepared his talk on the same subject by doing our laundry, cleaning the bedroom and the kitchen. He spoke impromptu on the subject, weaving an allegory of unselfishness out of the 3rd Battle of Ypres or Passchendaele or the Messines Ridge, which is celebrating its 90th anniversary. His only regret was not using the quote he thought up, that it is often said of the British army at the time were a bunch of lions led by asses, while he feels that one could say of us today that we are a bunch of asses led by lions. The comments I received afterward (mostly from women, being in primary and all) were either to express empathy with a German train story I told or to explain how their husbands were fascinated by the WWI battle and now wanted books on the subject. Not hard to blame them, since an explosion in Flanders that was heard in Dublin seems worth further reading.
A couple of months ago I read Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five and thought it was a good book. I was interested in how it changed my point of view on '50s and '60s science fiction as a addressing WWII as well as the Cold War. I was sad recently, however, to read on a "intellectual" Mormon group blog that many of them thought that it was vulgar and pornographic. First reactions was (admittedly like others on that blog) "huh? where? when?" and as I read more of the posts I was reminded of some bad language, two extra-marital affairs (no graphic sex), a visit to a porn shop (again, no graphic detail) and a juvenile drawing of a woman's breasts (if you've been to junior high, you've undoubtedly seen something similar).
It reminded me that I have thicker skin than many when it comes to what I can stand when I read a book or a watch a movie. I find that I tend to separate the message from the medium/media. That is, I justify the use of violence in a movie, if its use is to promote the message that war is bad.
Matt and I got into a long argument/discussion about this over started by Hemingway. I haven't read much Hemingway, but what I have I didn't like, but Matt's been reading him for his current class. What started as a discussion about the merits of reading Hemingway (or not) boiled down to a debate on how much the message or the medium has to do with whether a text is "good" or "art" or even just appreciated.
While my academic views are nearly all inclusive, by personal taste and views on the subject are not as inclusive. In my academic research I've been less interested in form and message than pure content, although in my greater study I am aware of the roles form and medium play. In my personal reading, I find that there is a more delicate balance of medium and message in what I like and don't like. For example, I hate many family-oriented films simply because they are cliché ridden. On the other hand, I loved the film V for Vendetta because it was unusual in story and action, even though the moral of that story might as well be anarchy.
So, dear readers, to take cue from Heidi's blog, where do you draw the line? When does the medium justify the message (eg war movies)? When does the message justify the medium (eg Mormon art)? Or do you believe (like Sergei Eisenstein) that the medium is the message (eg early Soviet film)?
Showing posts with label aesthetics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aesthetics. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

