Thursday, May 15, 2008

Rolling with Richard

We had assembled for lunch in the department library. I was the last to come as my meeting with the future graduate adviser have ran late. The only place left was between a trendy Scandinavian major and an older Scandinavian professor. The major ignored me, so I attempted conversation with the professor. I was trying to remember what she specifically studied while not looking vulgar while I ate the Mediterranean finger foods. I guessed medieval over philology. I was right, she did Icelandic medieval studies. Somehow we got on the topic of the class she was currently teaching.

"We are tracing the figure of Tristan from the medieval romances through Wagner and even to the recent movie," she paused looking curiously, "Your face lit up when I said 'Wagner' - do you like Wagner?"

A loaded question.

"Well, I'm afraid to admit that I'm starting to like Wagner. I used to think he was boring, but I saw The Flying Dutchman last fall and actually enjoyed it. Not that I'm ready to sit through the Ring or -"

She interrupted me with "You must see the Ring! It is an incredible experience, much better than listening to a recording. You have to be there and let yourself go, if you hold anything back you won't be transported by it. You have to let it take you in - you have to be Siegfried." And then she added with a smile "To hell with Brecht!"

By the end of lunch, in which she described in detail the Ring Cycles she had been to, I had committed myself to seeing the Ring.

Why did I do such a thing? The four operas together constitute fifteen hours of music. Music by Wagner. Is it not my long-held belief that Wagner had some good moments, but bad half hours? Did I not hold out many years against Steve the Bass Player's insistence that I would like Wagner?

When I got home, I told my sister, the musicologist, about my commitment. She commented she would only go if it were at Bayreuth - the home of the Wagner festival. Wagner in Bavaria seems perfect - if the productions stink you can console yourself with some Kaiserschmarrn.

She later added that she is beginning to like Wagner because she likes Strauss. This made perfect sense and planted a seed of doubt in my mind concerning these Richards. Within me grew a queasy feeling that I might really start liking Wagner.

Wagner seemed now to casually appear more often. First it was a u-tube night of watching that rascally rabbit and his hunter dressed as Vikings prancing to Wagner operas. I laughed, I sang along, and realized in an epiphany that the music was quite good, despite that fact it was being parodied. I dismissed this by remembering that the cartoon was only six minutes long, so there should be at least six minutes worth of good music in his oeuvre.

Then I started hearing wonderful opera overtures on the radio. I would drive along merrily listening until my brain had processed enough to conclude that it was Wagner. "Surely not," I told myself, "I'm enjoying this." Then suddenly I would have a vision of singing sailors and realize I was listening to The Flying Dutchman. Or a major theme from Tannhaeuser would arise and validate my conclusion. This was harder to explain away, but I came to the conclusion that my classical radio station plays just too many symphonies from the era of Mozart, but not by Mozart or Papa Haydn or any progeny of Bach, or anyone you've ever heard of. After a number of those, Wagner is a relief.

My complete resignation to Wagner came when I found this book on clearance: Wagner and His Operas. I knew I had to buy it and embrace Wagner.

I have been reluctant to appreciate Wagner because it is a sign that I am aging. I realize that certain dichotomies I set up in my youth are collapsing. You either like Brahms or Wagner, and I liked Brahms. But would it be possible to like both?

The Rolling Stones would suggest yes.

You see, at the same time I was discovering Wagner, I was discovering that I like the Rolling Stones. But I am a Beatles fan, which naturally precludes me from liking the Stones, so I thought. I used to believe they had only a couple of good songs - then I listened to their best of album and realized they had a number of good songs. And I realized it would be ok to like the Beatles and the Stones. In fact, listening to the Stones helps me understand the Beatles better, and vice verse.

I am resolved, then, to appreciate Wagner. My goal is to see at least one Wagner opera a year (I am allowing video recordings) and read this book on him. I bought Carolyn a copy so she can prepare too. It takes five to ten years of waiting to get tickets to Bayreuth. We ought to love him by then.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure age has anything to do with it. I'm older than dirt and still cannot imagine walking across the street to see Wagner. But I did see The Flying Dutchman a year or two ago...Papa

Amy Edwards said...

I still wish I had a spear and magic helmet.

Samuel said...

Kill the wabbit, kill the wabbit, kill the wabbit....

Anonymous said...

The Flying Dutchman was actually poignant and drew me in with the fine music as well. Years ago I thought when I went to Ludwig's castle that that would be the place to see a Wagner Opera. The perfect setting created especially for Wagner. I will have to check that out. Mutti

Carrie Nation said...

I had this discussion recently with a musicologist friend of mine who also discovered Wagner through Strauss. He's blocked off an entire week of his life next Spring (that's right, a year from now) to go to New York where the Met is doing the Ring cycle in one week. Somehow he convinced his wife to go with him.

I might have to agree with Nietzsche, who commented on one specific Wagner opera that it was the best symphony ever written. Not that I think it was the best symphony, but the point being, Wagner has some wonderful orchestration, but his weakness is ironically the voice, which in my opinion is where Strauss comes in. But of course, I'm biased.

Vanessa Swenson said...

If you're gonna do something, do it whole hog. Could Wagner be better than in Bavaria? I don't know, maybe I'll find out someday...

Thora said...

Being that I am completely ignorant of Wagner (although, it turns out that I did know pieces of him - from the cartoons, though), I turned to You Tube this last Saturday morning to educate myself. Avram and I watched recordings of the Ride of the Valkyries; that was good, of course. Than we turned to the operas, and watched bits of Parsifal, the Ring cycle (one with Brunhilde in a floor length leather coat, from the Bayreuth (sp?)). Avram really liked that one, but he knows the story of the Ring cycle. We also watched some others. Overall, I liked it when there was a translation, or summary at least, given on screen; if I didn't know what they were singing, I tended to tune out. Also, it's the first opera I've ever watched, so I think overall I'm qualified to say exactly nothing on the subject, besides that to me he had potential of listening to, and that I think I like just listening to music rather than watching operas. Avram kept on pointing out that he was anti-semitic, but maybe we'll get past that.
Thanks for expanding my horizons, Sarah.

Troop 152 said...

Anything you want to listen to is just fine, but if Barry Manilow or Rod Stewart ever start sounding good to you, that would be a major problem.
By the way, the DT thing is a good idea.

Anonymous said...

I love Bugs. I think kids today are being deprived of fine educational TV both in music and humor. (DVD advice, anyone?) I love the one where Bugs is Elmer Fudd's barber and flowers pop out of Elmer's skull in perfect timing to the music.

The Stones went up in my book when they spoofed themselves on the Simpsons. Mick Jagger teaching Homer, Apu, and Chief Wiggum how to strut, and Keith Richards being concerned about putting up storm windows is just fantastic.