One of the biggest downsides of this round of grad school is the intermittent insomnia. For whatever reason this week has been bad for sleeping. But good for catching up on all sorts of online things while lying awake in bed with your ipod. I got to read all sorts of anxiety filled posts from otherwise intelligent bloggers about the newest film installment of a certain veggie-vampires/wild-werewolves/typical-teenagers franchise. I've already blogged about this author before, but it still bothers me that quite a bit of the sort of self-righteous condemnation of the saga is because it is popular.
Also, am I the only person in the world who thinks that those books/films are campy?
Fortunately my annoyance was short-lived because I found this delightful article in the online version of a magazine of which, while I enjoy it, I tend to expect more emotional manipulation than intellectual engagement (and usually settle for a few spiritual warm fuzzies and a couple of good stories about young Hal Eyering).
I was so delighted, that I decided to find the longer article that this short piece was based on. Matt happened to take a class from the author on the very topic (well, literature and art of the Great War) so we were interested to see this published in that magazine.
And I did sleep eventually.
Friday, December 4, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


3 comments:
Glad to hear of someone who read said magazine online and enjoyed the article. More politics go into the making of these magazines than I ever thought. And that's all I'll say there.
No, you're not the only one who thinks they are campy. Some of my students who LOVED the books (at least the first one) H-A-T-E-D the movie. Much to their disappointment. Though I haven't read the books, I have seen the previews (can't avoid them; we go to movies and there they are), and I sense their campy, overly dramatic style. And then I think of the girls in my classes who filled every spare inch of their papers with "I love Edward" and signed their last names "Cullen." Ah, teenage girls. I remember things like that. Let them have their campiness. I remember an earlier condemnation of certain boy-wizard novels because they, too, were popular.
But guess what! They're reading! And they listen to, "If you like that, you might like this." And they discuss the books with others. Cool.
Your brother just recommended the article to me tonight. I'll have to get to the full-length edition as well.
Recently I cringed to hear my fellow GD teacher decry the waste of time and low moral character of the book series you referred to. The thing that really bothered me was my certainty that he must have made this judgment of the books based solely upon seeing a movie preview and perhaps a movie review he had read. I think I've shared with you before how the teenager inside me appreciated every heart flutter and sigh that annoyed your brother when he read them. Even the book I enjoyed least (the last) brought up wonderful ideas, especially near the end, that paralleled great questions about the eternal significance of spiritual gifts we now hold in embryo as well as creative ideas for what it might be like to experience new powers and abilities after resurrection. What did you think of the series as a whole, especially the last book? Have you read her latest? We, that is your brother and I, both really enjoyed it. ;)
Equinox and Chickadeedee: I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks they're campy. I think this author really captured the voice of an adolescent girl, but ever so subtly pokes fun at that whole time of life. Personally I think this comes out even more in the last book (or at least I assume the author was a good laugh when she gave the baby the name she did).
I also agree that whatever gets people to read is great. And I think that most people are actually better critical readers than we give them credit for. Along those lines, I don't think that all literature sold as "chidren's" or "young adult" needs to have a state approved pedagogical message.
I don't think they are of low moral character or a waste of time. I agree that people who do probably haven't read them or are threatened by the discussion of female sexuality and the resonances that has for a lot of people.
I also think there are more interesting existential and theological things going on in the books that most people caught up in the "aesthetics of abstinence" miss, like the examples you give, Chickadeedee.
Post a Comment