A Brief Report on the most recent church goings ons. The book club was a mild success, in that two people came this time and we got the next two months assigned. In August we are reading a book about the languages of love (there are apparently five of them) and how to improve communication with our spouses. I suppose these languages will be French, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish and, um, Romanian? We will see.
Our talks went well. I finally finished reading the last book of a multi-volume fantasy series with overtly Christian themes (no, not the one with the lion, the one that also masquerades as a Bildungsroman , or better yet, the great British boarding school multi-part novel). Since I no longer had any excuses, I wrote my talk out on overcoming selfishness on Sunday morning. I managed to refer to said fantasy book, Lacan's mirror theory and Nietzsche, so although I forgot the Goethe quote I was going to put in, I called it a success. Matt prepared his talk on the same subject by doing our laundry, cleaning the bedroom and the kitchen. He spoke impromptu on the subject, weaving an allegory of unselfishness out of the 3rd Battle of Ypres or Passchendaele or the Messines Ridge, which is celebrating its 90th anniversary. His only regret was not using the quote he thought up, that it is often said of the British army at the time were a bunch of lions led by asses, while he feels that one could say of us today that we are a bunch of asses led by lions. The comments I received afterward (mostly from women, being in primary and all) were either to express empathy with a German train story I told or to explain how their husbands were fascinated by the WWI battle and now wanted books on the subject. Not hard to blame them, since an explosion in Flanders that was heard in Dublin seems worth further reading.
A couple of months ago I read Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five and thought it was a good book. I was interested in how it changed my point of view on '50s and '60s science fiction as a addressing WWII as well as the Cold War. I was sad recently, however, to read on a "intellectual" Mormon group blog that many of them thought that it was vulgar and pornographic. First reactions was (admittedly like others on that blog) "huh? where? when?" and as I read more of the posts I was reminded of some bad language, two extra-marital affairs (no graphic sex), a visit to a porn shop (again, no graphic detail) and a juvenile drawing of a woman's breasts (if you've been to junior high, you've undoubtedly seen something similar).
It reminded me that I have thicker skin than many when it comes to what I can stand when I read a book or a watch a movie. I find that I tend to separate the message from the medium/media. That is, I justify the use of violence in a movie, if its use is to promote the message that war is bad.
Matt and I got into a long argument/discussion about this over started by Hemingway. I haven't read much Hemingway, but what I have I didn't like, but Matt's been reading him for his current class. What started as a discussion about the merits of reading Hemingway (or not) boiled down to a debate on how much the message or the medium has to do with whether a text is "good" or "art" or even just appreciated.
While my academic views are nearly all inclusive, by personal taste and views on the subject are not as inclusive. In my academic research I've been less interested in form and message than pure content, although in my greater study I am aware of the roles form and medium play. In my personal reading, I find that there is a more delicate balance of medium and message in what I like and don't like. For example, I hate many family-oriented films simply because they are cliché ridden. On the other hand, I loved the film V for Vendetta because it was unusual in story and action, even though the moral of that story might as well be anarchy.
So, dear readers, to take cue from Heidi's blog, where do you draw the line? When does the medium justify the message (eg war movies)? When does the message justify the medium (eg Mormon art)? Or do you believe (like Sergei Eisenstein) that the medium is the message (eg early Soviet film)?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


8 comments:
That is an interesting question. From a psychological standpoint I do not think that we can separate form and medium from the message. They are both too interconnected, and we must look at the entire piece to formulate an opinion. For me, I think the answer must lie in the viewer. There are certain things that I simply will not view or read, but I still consider to be good art and have no problem if others like it. There are even some things that I consider to be bad art that I have no problem with people liking. I think it is a matter of what we are able to process and glean from the art that is important. That said I also think that there are some things where either the medium or the message is simply too sick to justify the good that comes with it.
It's probably for the best that Matt didn't use his lions and asses quote. I can't imagine that a Mapleton ward is too "J Golden," as it were.
You should show the book club the Legacy clips in various romance languages to see which one wins out: "mes mains, mon amour, ma foi" or maybe "mis manos, mi amor, mi fe" but really, I think "minhas mãos, meu amor, minha fé" sounds great.
Slaughterhouse Five was one of the books that I took with me to Europe. What I found most interesting about the book was how it was seemingly scatterbrained just as a bombing like Dresden or Guernica would have felt to those being attacked. I was in the middle of the book when my dad and I stumbled onto Guernica. It was eerie. The city was eerie in that it was pretty much completely rebuilt, but there was a memorial and a replica of the painting on a wall. Anyway, it was an interesting read made all the more poignant once we stumbled onto Gernika.
But I'm with you, I'm not as shocked when I read things, but I can see how others in Utah Mormondom would get freaked by the book. But honestly, why is it a few words disgust people and not the bombing of Dresden? Did anyone blog about the horrific nature of that incident? What's worse: the F-word or the firebombing of Dresden? Hmmm. Okay, rant over.
Oh, like Samuel, I think it can be hard to separate the medium from the message, and I reject the idea that one is supremely more important than the other. Such absolutes in man-made items are sort of useless because nothing we make is perfect, so how could an item be exactly 100% better than anything else? I wonder sometimes, though, if the great philosophers don't tend to go to one extreme for the sake of making us talk about something more middle ground, bouncing various ideas and concepts around while finding our way in the middle. (I have this mental picture of the iron rod in the Great Middle of life: let go on one side and you fall into Babylon, let go on the other and you fall into religious zealousness, focusing on only one or two aspects that dominate.) Even if these philosophers don't mean to do such, I think it's what happens anyway.
Ack. I've blogged on your blog again. I blame your insightful entries for my excessive verbosity. But don't stop, because I do love them so.
Samuel - you take a very mature attitude. I find it hard to let other people have opinions about art that differ vastly from my own. For example, I don't consider a certain Mormon favorite "Painter of Light" and all of his pastel English cottage scenes to be art and I tend to disdain those who do. I need to be better at live and let live.
Venom - I think you make a good point about Slaughterhouse Five . It seems strange to get caught up on two f-words when an entire city has been fire-bombed. But that's part of the problem, right? If we can't get past the medium for the message, then what are we left with? A couple of f-words, if you've read Vonnegut. A manipulation of emotions, if you've been to EFY. I have to agree with you (and Samuel) that the medium cannot be extracted from the message and vice versa, but I'm having a hard time reconciling the justification of one for the other.
The problem extends not only to art, but just about everything. For example, the KJV. It was purposefully written in archaic language (even in archaic language for the time it was written/translated). How does that affect the message? I would say it makes us have to stretch to understand its meaning - not just to understand the Bible's ancient cultures, but just to figure what it is even saying. We have to study it and understand old word choice and usage, syntax and all of that linguistic stuff to be able to read it.
We have to progress and learn to understand the message, which seems to mean, that God can only be reached by long study and education. Do we believe this? To a certain degree, I believe we do, that we should always be striving to understand God better. On the other hand, I don't think God is as inaccessible as archaic English is to many of us.
Hmm, now I've blogged in my comments.
Anyone else got 2cents to add?
I'm wondering if we feel that we can control the f-words more than a terrible bombing, so we take more immediate disgust at the swearing?
Oh, about the KJV, interesting point. But I also think that we're afraid to translate religious/spiritual texts into our normal language for fear of lowering it or something. Nonetheless, it makes us work.
But then because of this respect (often deservedly so) if we say anything "bad" about something with a religious tinge, even if it's not attacking the subject matter.
Example:
This picture
It's something I imagine we all want, to one day be reunited with our God. But the painting is terrible. It looks like a cartoon. Christ also looks like He is 6'8". Paintings like this are very different from the idea of the KJV translation. How much do you have to think and learn? Do we at all?
Mormon art is that perfect example of force-fed kitsch.
But if we see something like this, we're allowed to freak out. Cartoon! It's not a bad cartoon, as this type of cartooning goes. But the banal nature of it all...
(I don't like the cartoon, btw)
What about this? this? It's terrible! I hate Kinkade!
But now how about this piece, called A Prayer for Peace? Can people say anything against this painting, now? I can. I hate Kinkade. But I the topic of the painting is nice.
I know it's hard to separate message from medium, because they're so intertwined often. But sometimes I think separating the message from the medium is what saves the message or medium depending. (Radio's better without Imus, for example. Can you imagine how much it'd improve without Howard Stern?)
I just don't like Mormon art so much that I separate easily. Too much focus on message to the point that the medium doesn't matter.
Oh, I don't like Arnold Friberg very much, either, ok, not at all, but I still think that Captain Moroni's pretty cool.
I know you asked for other people to comment, but this entry's fun.
On the subject of Mormon Art, I have to say Minerva Teichert is my favorite artist. But, I know this isn't about Mormon Art.
Upon watching Mr. Monk and the Rapper, I decided that rap itself wouldn't be that bad, but it usually has connections vulgar ideas, and words, usually degrading to women in some form or another. So is it rap itself that is bad, or just because bad things are put into the rap. For now, I avoid rap in general.
Also, because the majority of Mormon Art is degrading to the intelligence for the most part, I avoid that as well.
However, I admit to owning various Michael McLean mp3s. And a few EFY songs, because of the remembrances they bring. And I've read all 10 Work and the Glory, but that was when I was younger. I may not have liked them now. But, like rap, I avoid Mormon Pop like the plague for the most part.
I do believe it is very difficult to divide the medium from the message (think of cringing during a Sacrament Meeting musical number performance o f His Hands....) But, sometimes it is possible, and sometimes necessary.
Well this is a little bit out on a limb with the conversation but I feel is relevant.
War movies-
It seems that Violence is justified in War Movies to be accurate to the history. As if this implies that blood is all that makes history accurate. I have had a lot of friends who say, "My Grandfather says war was excatly like it was depicted in "Saving Private Ryan" and so to better understand history I watch that because it was so real.
Violence has a place in movies and history. However if you are trying to learn history I find you need very little violence to achieve Historical learning in film.
Many Documentaries provide excellent history that is easily comprehended.
Some would argue though that it doesn't let us feel what it was like to be their. Should we try to feel that? Film provides a visual medium it lets us see the blood and the mud which is what most war movies are. However we are free of pain and suffering, oh sure some of us may get teary eyed when a character died but this is simulated emotion. Along the lines of feeling like we were really there then we should spend weeks in mud and cold having potshots taken at us by the opposing side while our friends get gangrene and have their leg amputated.(That would be some re-enactment for you)
Okay okay so what is the purpose of the violence in war films? As a historian I am going to put it like this...ENTERTAINMENT.
If it were learning it could be achieved through other medium or methods and could better expressed through those.
So in the notes of film don't justify violence as learning.
On the flip side books and such I find that some are willing to declare some things pornographic while the close the eye intende pornographic works that slip under the radar. You to can visit the BYU Pornography section and you don't even need a special key to access it. Romance novels are porn. Sure they aren't visual and are mostly softcore but If you stood up in public in Utah and began to read those people would try to have you arrested. Yet we turn a blind Eye and call literature Pornography and fictious romantic encounters with semiclad scottsmen in dark and lonely castles that we have been forced to enter because of a sudden thunder storm which render our clothing nigh to transparent and has forced us to disrobe..... okay I think I made the point.
Both of my arguements come down to the intent of the producer. Many see David as obscene because he is naked yet that was not the intent of the painting. While Underwear adds to excite and titulate receive no protest from these same people.
Sadly some shall always blind themselves the the very evils they protest.
You all bring up good points. I think Venom's collage of pictures is a nice way of looking at the problem. It brings into view nicely Heidi's question of whether there are some media not appropriate to some messages.
I think that's part of what makes art art - how well the medium matches the message. For example, Bach dedicated everything he wrote to God. From Bach's music (and I'm grossly generalizing) we learn God is both complex and beautiful, which I think is certainly a component of his person.
From Mormon pop we learn that God is cliche and emotionally manipulative, which I certainly hope is not true. But part of that is the problem that it is "pop" meant to appeal to the lowest common denominator, meant to sell.
So now we have the problem that Travis brought up, that is, intent. I tried to find the quote from the Ensign that said something to the effect that pornography could be porn for you, even if it didn't have that intended effect. In essence, pornography is relative, so we're back to Samuel.
But Travis makes a good point too, that the message is overlooked because of the medium, as in the case of romance novels versus pictorial pornography. Porn doesn't exist in writing, right?
I also appreciate Travis's point that war movies are entertainment. I went to a writer's conference once where a woman who wrote historical fiction said you can't make things too period other wise the author doesn't believe you. My grandfather who was at 3 D-Days (yes, there were more than one - he was at North Africa, Sicily, and Southern France) was interviewed a little bit ago about what it was like the days before the invasion. He said boring, a lot of hurry up and wait. The reporter didn't like that answer, so she didn't include it in the article.
I believe war movies don't show the whole picture and a lot of them have excessive violence, but I can't quite throw them all out as not having executed well their message. I certainly acknowledge the entertainment factor, but I think film (especially) often has another agenda.
So now we're onto a new problem - are some messages better suited for some media?
messages and media...messages and media.
So I was thinking that the scriptures aren't really suited for cartoonish media last night as I was falling asleep. Oh, and Elijah
But then I was reminded of Prince of Egypt. I actually really liked the movie, even though I wasn't expecting to.
So now I'm left still pondering if certain media is better for certain messages or if it's just the handling of the message within the media...I'll keep thinking.
In the meanwhile, enjoy the videos.
Oh, and I don't know about Lego Stills. Sorta weird.
Post a Comment